Today, with your leave, we are going to try something a bit different on The Global Indian Series: a debate. Our motion is as follows: ‘This House believes that India’s decision to abstain from U.N. vote against Russia was craven”

In the interests of fairness, we shall put forward both sides of the argument, after which you, dear reader, can decide where the truth lies.


The first point to make in in India’s defence is this: abstention does not mean it condones Putin’s War. On the contrary. Prime Minister Narendra Modi in his telephone conversation with Putin last Thursday appealed for an “immediate cessation of violence.” Modi urged him to return to diplomacy, saying the “differences between Russia and the NATO group can only be resolved through honest and sincere dialogue.”

The Indian Geo-Political Headache

India’s finds itself in a delicate position. On the one hand, it needs to keep the US and the West sweet. On the other, it is very loath to antagonise Russia with whom it has long had close diplomatic ties. It needs both in order to check the growing power of China in the region.
India’s first duty is protect her own interests and those of her people. To blame a country for treading carefully so as not to jeopardise the balance of power is naive.

Historically, India depended on Soviet support and its veto power in the Security Council in its dispute over Kashmir with sworn enemy Pakistan and this remains the case today. So much is at stake for India.

Money and Missiles

It is not just a question of geopolitics, it is about money too.  According to the motion, This house believes that India’s decision to abstain from U.N. vote against Russia was craven." We beg to differ. . India and Russia have set a target of $30 billion in bilateral trade by the end of 2025. India depends upon Russian oil and gas. Had India used its vote to rebuke Russia, relations would undoubtedly have soured and this in turn might have jeopardised the trade deal and therefore cost India thousands of much-needed jobs. It is highly likely, too, that Russia would have retaliated by raising oil and gas prices.

Tensions with China

Further complicating matter is that India locked in a 2, 100 mile border dispute with China in the Himalayan region. India hopes that Russia can bring its influence to bear and persuade China to cede Aksai Chin and land south of the McMahon line to India. The border can shift owing to the presence of rivers, lakes and snowcaps. Relations worsened after a clash with Chinese troops at Ladakh in 2021 in which at least twenty Indian soldiers were killed.

Both nuclear powers (which have two of the world’s largest armies) are racing to build roads and infrastructure on the disputed border, which has only served to make matters worse.

India alleges China sent thousands of troops into Ladakh's Galwan valley and that China occupies 38,000sq km (14,700sq miles) of her territory.

Talks in the last three decades have failed and the 1962 Sino-Indian war (when India was soundly beaten) still is a source of gall and wormwood to Indians.

A Tinder Box

The situation is a tinderbox. All it would take is one match to light it.

Small wonder has had to put realpolitik before emotion. In doing so, India is not siding with Russia, but India is playing a long game. Few countries envy the stakes and intricacies of India’s foreign policy and one needs the wisdom of Solomon to curb Chinese power without upsetting Russia and the West.


India is quite rightly proud to be the world’s biggest democracy and as such it should set an example to the world. Abstaining from the vote in the UN was a sin of omission. Had India had the moral courage to take a stand against Putin, doing so would have sent a message to the Kremlin:

“Mr. Putin, Realpolitik does not trump morality. We might need your alliance to counter Chinese power, we might buy your arms, you might need your oil and your gas and we might need your support over Kashmir, but, you sir, are a war-monger and a bully. To invade a sovereign state for no good reason apart from the fact that you covet it was the act of a Stalin or a Hitler. We’ve keep the receipt for S-400 missile system, and although it gives us a much-needed deterrent against China and Pakistan, we want our money back.”

Besides, the deal puts us at risk of U.S. sanctions asked its allies to stay away from Russian military equipment.

But realpolitik and self-interest triumphed, did they not? Shame on you.

Now, it’s over to you. Where do you stand on the matter?


Support change: A little favour to ask-We believe true freedom is to be able to act without fear or favour and that identity is not a “brand” to be abused, politicized, or reduced for personal gain. As Global Indians, the need to work together is greater now than ever before.  If we want to see real change, we need to create a better society for all, tackle injustice and plunge into the many aspects of what the human experience truly offers.The Global Indian Series has been built to be a platform of integrity, fairness and to remain fiercely independent of political influence. We are the first in the world to connect with every echelon of society with all human voices being treated equally.  We are the first to have travelled physically to locations far and wide, often putting our own lives on the line to bring forward stories that deserve to be told.  Whether it’s through our Podcast that delves into the human experience behind identity, our articles and features that cover key events we need to know, or live based events that tackle topical discussions, we have been there to support a better community and planet.Despite the high costs and time needed to maintain our work, we continue, because we know our work has helped more people understand what is happening within the communities across our planet, why it matters, and how, together, we can demand progress.  We challenge head-on, the silent divisions that have crept into our collective consciousness and how to tackle key issues that often go neglected in mainstream media.How you can help:Please share our work: By collaborating with others who share our values, our combined voices make change, with many more becoming inspired to take meaningful action.Subscribe to the platform:Many from across our community have decided to subscribe to our platform. It helps us grow which in turns attracts like-minded supporters. If you have not already, we would appreciate you subscribing to our newsletters and following our social media accounts. It is free and supports our journey.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *